Austin Group Defect Tracker

Aardvark Mark IV

Viewing Issue Simple Details Jump to Notes ] Issue History ] Print ]
ID Category Severity Type Date Submitted Last Update
0001479 [1003.1(2016/18)/Issue7+TC2] Shell and Utilities Objection Clarification Requested 2021-05-28 09:14 2021-12-13 15:20
Reporter geoffclare View Status public  
Assigned To
Priority normal Resolution Accepted  
Status Applied  
Name Geoff Clare
Organization The Open Group
User Reference
Section make
Page Number 2980
Line Number 98946
Interp Status ---
Final Accepted Text
Summary 0001479: Not clear what "achieve results" means for make defaults
Description The description of the make utility says "The default rules for make shall achieve results that are the same as if the following were used" and then goes on to specify, among other things, default values for some macros.

It is not clear what is intended by "achieve results". In particular if these results include the output written to standard output by make when it executes a shell command, then the only way to achieve the same results would be for the defaults to be exactly those that are specified in the standard. However, just excluding that output would not fix the problem because a command such as "echo $(CFLAGS) > outfile" would produce different contents in outfile if CFLAGS does not have exactly the specified default value.

A quick check of the Solaris and GNU make implementations reveals the following differences from the defaults specified in the standard:

Both have ARFLAGS=rv (instead of ARFLAGS=-rv)
Both have CC=cc (instead of CC=c99)
Both have CFLAGS= (empty instead of CFLAGS=-O 1)
GNU has SCCSGETFLAGS= (empty instead of SCCSGETFLAGS=-s)

The proposed change would allow the first three but not the GNU SCCSGETFLAGS value, which hopefully the GNU make maintainer will not object to changing.
Desired Action Change:
The default rules for make shall achieve results that are the same as if the following were used.
The default rules and macro values for make shall achieve results that are the same as if the following were used, except that where a result includes the literal value of a macro, this value may differ.

Tags tc3-2008
Attached Files

- Relationships

-  Notes
psmith (developer)
2021-05-28 12:56

I have no problem with changing SCCSGETFLAGS.

I would like to point out that "CFLAGS=-O 1" is (IMO) a bug in the standard and this should be "CFLAGS=-O1" (no space). Some compilers (GCC, for example) do not allow space between "-O" and its argument.

For portability, the standard should not require CFLAGS to be set to a non-portable value by default.

$ touch /tmp/foo.c
$ cc -O1 -c /tmp/foo.c
$ cc -O 1 -c /tmp/foo.c
cc: error: 1: No such file or directory
joerg (reporter)
2021-05-28 13:23
edited on: 2021-05-28 13:32

ARFLAGS= without a leading dash is historic practice that still works
on all ar implementations I am aware of.

I am not shure whether any compiler supports -O 1 with a space.
This seems to be a definite text formatting bug in the standard.

Regarding CC=c99, if everybody believes this is what should be used,
given that SunPro Make in it's current configuration decides how to
behave at runtime, when called as /usr/xpg4/bin/make, it would be
possible to let it read /usr/share/lib/make/posix.make.rules instead of
/usr/share/lib/make/make.rules and change that file to define CC=c99.

Should this be done? Reading posix.make.rules in that case would be
three additional lines of code.

geoffclare (manager)
2021-05-28 13:33

I think the standard has -O 1 with a space because conforming applications are required to pass the -O and the 1 as separate arguments to c99 (see XBD 12.1 item 2a). The c99 utility is required to accept them either separately or together.

An implementation can of course set the default CFLAGS to -O1 without the space under the "shall achieve results that are the same" wording that is the subject of this bug.

Setting the default CC to cc instead of c99 is fine on a particular implementation provided a conforming application compiled with cc behaves the same as if it was compiled with c99. (Remember that a conforming application must define _POSIX_C_SOURCE=200809 or _XOPEN_SOURCE=700.)
psmith (developer)
2021-05-28 13:53

Actually, GNU make already has conforming values of CC, SCCSGETFLAGS, and ARFLAGS if you set .POSIX:

$ cat > Makefile
all: ; @echo $(CC) / $(SCCSGETFLAGS) / $(ARFLAGS)

$ make
c99 / -s / -rv
joerg (reporter)
2021-05-28 13:57

I just checked Sun Studio c99 and you seem to be correct. -O 1 is
geoffclare (manager)
2021-05-28 15:02

Re Note: 0005369 My bad for doing my checks without a .POSIX target.

I have re-checked Solaris with .POSIX, and ARFLAGS changes to -rv but CC and CFLAGS are still the same.
joerg (reporter)
2021-05-28 15:14

Yes, this is line 3029 from file

I did not know that. It seems to overwrite things at runtime
and it may be the only way to do this since .POSIX may be seen
after /usr/share/lib/make/make.rules has been read.

That block could be enhanced to also overwrite CC and CFLAGS.
psmith (developer)
2021-05-28 16:10

FWIW, GNU make won't change CFLAGS to "-O 1" even in POSIX mode. GCC (run as c99) will fail if that is done and in this case the real world must prevail over small conformance issues :).

Someone can mention this (not accepting "-O 1") to the GCC folks but I would be surprised if they felt that conformance in this situation was worth the effort I suspect would be involved with making it work (but I could be wrong, it could be easy). Nevertheless there are enough c99's out there where it fails today, that it's not feasible to change it in GNU make.

I understand that this is not being asked.

- Issue History
Date Modified Username Field Change
2021-05-28 09:14 geoffclare New Issue
2021-05-28 09:14 geoffclare Name => Geoff Clare
2021-05-28 09:14 geoffclare Organization => The Open Group
2021-05-28 09:14 geoffclare Section => make
2021-05-28 09:14 geoffclare Page Number => 2980
2021-05-28 09:14 geoffclare Line Number => 98946
2021-05-28 09:14 geoffclare Interp Status => ---
2021-05-28 12:56 psmith Note Added: 0005366
2021-05-28 13:23 joerg Note Added: 0005367
2021-05-28 13:24 joerg Note Edited: 0005367
2021-05-28 13:32 joerg Note Edited: 0005367
2021-05-28 13:33 geoffclare Note Added: 0005368
2021-05-28 13:53 psmith Note Added: 0005369
2021-05-28 13:57 joerg Note Added: 0005370
2021-05-28 15:02 geoffclare Note Added: 0005371
2021-05-28 15:14 joerg Note Added: 0005372
2021-05-28 16:10 psmith Note Added: 0005373
2021-11-18 17:12 Don Cragun Status New => Resolved
2021-11-18 17:12 Don Cragun Resolution Open => Accepted
2021-11-18 17:13 Don Cragun Tag Attached: tc3-2008
2021-12-13 15:20 geoffclare Status Resolved => Applied

Mantis 1.1.6[^]
Copyright © 2000 - 2008 Mantis Group
Powered by Mantis Bugtracker